Market downturns are not a question of if, but when: since 2000, investors have lived through the dot-com crash, the 2008 financial crisis, the 2020 pandemic selloff as well as the 2022 slide that hit stocks and bonds simultaneously. For a working investor, a downturn is unsettling but for someone living off their savings, it can permanently change their retirement outlook. For someone only a few years from retirement, a poorly timed market correction can push back the date they planned to stop working. The good news is that while you can’t control the market, you can control how prepared you (and your portfolio) are for this eventuality.
Why Timing Matters More in Retirement
While you’re saving, a falling market means you’re buying at lower prices. Once you start withdrawing, this calculation reverses: selling assets during a market downturn to cover living expenses effectively locks in any losses and leaves you with fewer shares to benefit from when markets recover.
This is called sequence-of-returns risk. Two retirees can earn the same average return over a 20-year investment period and end up with very different results. One investor’s portfolio can be hit by a bear market during the first year of retirement and the other a few years later. The early years of retirement are when your portfolio is most vulnerable.
5 Questions to Ask Your Advisor
- Do you have a cash buffer?
Holding one to three years of planned withdrawals in cash, money market funds or short-term bonds (collectively referred to as cash and cash equivalents) lets you cover expenses without selling stocks at a loss. This gives your growth assets time to recover.
- Does your asset allocation match your real risk tolerance?
Holding an aggressive portfolio feels encouraging in a rising market. A better test is to ask how you would feel, and more importantly how you would react if your portfolio dropped by 30%. For context, in early 2020, the S&P 500 fell about 34% in roughly a month. If that scenario would push you to sell, your allocation may be too aggressive.
- Is your retirement portfolio diversified to limit volatility?
Diversification is the foundation of a retirement portfolio built to withstand a downturn. The goal isn’t to avoid losses altogether, but to limit how far your portfolio falls so you aren’t forced to sell at the bottom or delay retirement. This matters most when your time horizon is short. An investor in their 30s can wait out a long recovery, but someone five years from retirement may not have that luxury. After the 2008 financial crisis, the S&P 500 took about five and a half years to climb back to its 2007 high. For someone planning to retire in 2009, a drop like that could have meant working several more years.
High-quality bonds have often moved in the opposite direction of stocks during periods of market stress. When investors get nervous, they tend to move money into safer assets like US Treasuries, which pushes bond prices up as stocks fall. In 2008, the S&P 500 fell about 37% while the broad US bond market gained roughly 5%. In the first quarter of 2020, stocks fell about 20% while bonds gained about 3%.
That relationship isn’t guaranteed, however. In 2022, rising inflation and rapid interest rate increases pushed both down together: the S&P 500 lost approximately 18% and the broad US bond market fell roughly 13%. It was a rare occasion where this traditional buffer did not hold up. Shorter-term bonds, which are less sensitive to interest rates, held up considerably better. Spreading your bond holdings across different maturities and credit qualities can help your retirement portfolio hold up in different kinds of downturns.
Not all stocks behave the same way in a downturn. Defensive sectors such as consumer staples, utilities and healthcare sell products people need regardless of the economy, and they have historically tended to fall less than the broader market. In 2022, while the S&P 500 lost about 18%, the utilities and consumer staples sectors finished roughly flat. Spreading investments across regions, including international markets, adds another layer of diversification.
The balance between growth and dividend-paying stocks matters too. Growth stocks, often concentrated in technology, can deliver strong returns in rising markets but tend to fall harder when markets turn. In 2022, US large-cap growth stocks lost about 29%, while value stocks, a group that includes many established dividend payers, lost about 8%. Dividends can also provide retirement income, reducing the need to sell shares when prices are down, although companies can cut dividends in a severe downturn, as many did in 2008–09.
Some investors try sector rotation, shifting from economically sensitive sectors into defensive ones as conditions change. Timing those shifts consistently is difficult, however, and for most retirees, a steady allocation that already includes defensive sectors tends to be more dependable than trying to rotate at the right moment.
Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) offer broad diversification in a single holding, generally at low cost, and tend to be tax-efficient in taxable accounts. Mutual funds can offer active professional management and easy automatic investing, but they can distribute taxable capital gains even in years when the fund loses value, as many did in 2022. Individual stocks and bonds offer the most control, such as holding a bond to maturity or selling a specific position for a tax loss, but they require a larger portfolio and closer oversight to diversify properly. Many retirement portfolios combine all three: a core of low-cost funds, complemented by individual holdings where they add control or tax benefits.
Asset allocation is what you own; asset location is where you own it. Most retirees hold savings across three types of accounts. Taxable accounts, such as brokerage accounts, are taxed each year on dividends, interest and realized gains. Tax-deferred accounts, such as traditional IRAs and 401(k)s, are taxed as ordinary income when you withdraw. Tax-free accounts, such as Roth IRAs and Roth 401(k)s, allow qualified withdrawals with no tax at all.
A common approach is to hold income-producing investments like taxable bonds in tax-deferred accounts, place the assets with the highest growth potential in Roth accounts where that growth is never taxed, and keep tax-efficient investments such as broad-market ETFs in taxable accounts. Asset location also gives you more options during a downturn. You can draw income from whichever account holds assets that haven’t fallen, such as cash or bonds, while your stocks recover. In a taxable account, you can sell positions at a loss to offset capital gains and up to $3,000 of ordinary income each year.
A downturn can also be an opportune time to convert part of a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA: with account values temporarily lower, you pay tax on a smaller amount, and the recovery happens inside a tax-free account. Because these decisions depend on your full tax picture, they are best made with your advisor and tax professional.
Over time, market movements pull a portfolio away from its target mix. Rebalancing brings it back, and in doing so builds in the discipline to sell what has risen and buy what has fallen. One common method is threshold rebalancing: you set a target mix, such as 60% stocks and 40% bonds, and rebalance whenever an asset class drifts more than five percentage points from that target. For example, if stocks fall 30% while bonds hold steady, a $1,000,000 portfolio would drop to $820,000, with stocks making up only about 51%. Rebalancing would mean selling about $72,000 of bonds and buying stocks at lower prices to restore the 60/40 mix.
There are other ways to rebalance, such as on a set schedule once or twice a year, or by directing new contributions and withdrawals toward whichever asset class is out of line. It also helps to rebalance inside tax-deferred and tax-free accounts where possible, since trades there don’t trigger capital gains taxes. The right method depends on your situation, which makes it a valuable conversation to have with your advisor.
- Is your withdrawal strategy flexible?
A fixed annual withdrawal schedule that rises along with inflation does not adjust during a market downturn. Modestly trimming discretionary spending during a down year or skipping an inflation increase can meaningfully extend how long your retirement savings last.
- Are your essential expenses covered by reliable income?
Social Security, pensions, and annuities do not fluctuate during unexpected market conditions. If these sources of income cover core costs like housing, food, and healthcare, a market downturn affects your discretionary spending rather than your essentials. Also make sure these income sources are adequate to help keep up with the rising costs of inflation over time.
The Biggest Risk May Be Your Own Reaction
Market downturns hold real risk, but reacting out of panic often holds more. Investors who sold near the bottom in March 2009 or March 2020 missed some of the strongest market recoveries on record. The US stock market has historically recovered from every major decline, though some recoveries have taken years. Selling at, or near, the bottom turns a temporary decline into a permanent loss.
An investment strategy made during stable market conditions is your best defense against emotional decisions made in volatile ones. If you decide in advance which assets to draw from to cover living expenses, when to rebalance your portfolio and how to adjust your spending, if necessary, it becomes much easier to stay the course.
The best time to stress-test your retirement portfolio is before market conditions force you to do so. If you’re not sure how your plan would hold up in the next market downturn, a conversation with a financial advisor can help you identify the gaps in your portfolio and assist in creating a more robust allocation. Contact us today to get started.
More helpful articles:
- Will My Retirement Savings Last?
- The Hidden Cost of Retirement: Why Withdrawal Strategy Matters


